In this comparison article for Purina ONE vs. Purina PRO PLAN vs. Royal Canin, I will review some of their best-selling products and highlight the main differences between these well-established brands.
Purina is notable for its affordability and consistency in producing hearty meals. While they source their quality ingredients from trusted suppliers across the world, they limit their operations in Purina-owned facilities in America and Canada for your peace of mind. As such, their products meet strict AAFCO, FDA, and USDA nutritional standards.
Royal Canin also prides in their positive track record. This brand boasts of a stellar reputation of doing stringent lab testing and trials with their products. However, feeding your beloved pet Royal Canin products also demands a big budget.
That is why some guardians/fur-parents are wondering if switching to a more affordable alternative, such as Purina, is worth the try.
Hopefully, this comparison review will help you make an informed decision.
- The Purina PRO PLAN FOCUS Sensitive Skin & Stomach Formula provides a hearty meal for your canine buddy. This kibble features salmon as its #1 ingredient. Plus, it has barley, ground rice, and oatmeal, all of which supply complex carbs for energy and fiber for proper digestion.
- Picky eaters would find it hard to resist the savory taste of Purina PRO PLAN SAVOR Shredded Blend of Chicken & Rice Recipe. If you have a skinny pooch needing to gain a few pounds, this is the easiest way to go!
- The Purina ONE SMARTBLEND Chicken & Rice Recipe is a good all-rounder for healthy adult dogs. This dog food supplies a well-balanced amount of protein, fat, and carbs. Best of all, this kibble includes meaty bits!
- Got a canine dynamo at home? The Purina ONE SMARTBLEND True Instinct with Chicken & Venison offers 30% protein to keep those muscles lean and strong.
- The Royal Canin German Shepherd Adult Dog Food has set the bar high. Many guardians/pet parents are impressed with how this food improved the digestive health, appearance, and energy levels of their GSDs.
- Greedy Labs can satisfy themselves with the Royal Canin Labrador Retriever Adult Dog Food. This paw-licking kibble supplies fewer calories, but it is packed with essential nutrients Labs need to look and perform their best.
Main Differences
The main differences between Purina ONE vs. Purina PRO PLAN Vs. Royal Canin are:
Comparisson Table
Model | Weight | Breed size | Main ingredient | Price |
---|---|---|---|---|
30.0 pounds | Small Breeds, Medium Breeds, Large Breeds, All Breeds | Salmon | Check Price | |
35.0 pounds | Small Breeds, Medium Breeds, Large Breeds, All Breeds | Chicken | Check Price | |
40.0 pounds | Small Breeds, Medium Breeds, Large Breeds, All Breeds | Chicken | Check Price | |
36.0 pounds | Small Breeds, Medium Breeds, Large Breeds, All Breeds | Turkey | Check Price | |
30.0 pounds | Large Breeds | Brewer’s rice, chicken by-product meal | Check Price | |
30.0 pounds | Large Breeds | Chicken by-product meal | Check Price |
Purina ONE vs. Purina PRO PLAN vs. Royal Canin: Product Reviews
Purina ONE, Purina PRO PLAN, and Royal Canin have invested countless recipes encompassing different life stages, flavors, and specific nutritional requirements to accommodate the needs of our furry pals. In this face-off, I will be looking at a few of their most popular formulas.
Purina PRO PLAN FOCUS Sensitive Skin & Stomach Formula for Adult Dogs, Salmon & Rice
Each bowl of Purina Pro Plan FOCUS Sensitive Skin & Stomach Formula is a step to healthier skin and shinier, thicker, softer coat! This recipe features salmon as its main ingredient, which is the richest source of omega-3 in any type of fish. Likewise, Purina boosted the protein content of the food by adding salmon meal.
This recipe also features barley, ground rice, and oatmeal. These grains are an excellent source of complex carbohydrates, dietary fiber, B vitamins, and niacin, among other minerals. As such, these ingredients promote proper digestion and bowel movement.
Moreover, Purina added sunflower oil and fish oil to the formula, both of which provide protein, fat, and omega fatty acids. A diet rich in essential fatty acids promotes cardiovascular health and improves cognitive function, as well as inhibits pain and inflammation caused by arthritis.
As with any Purina product, it is manufactured in Purina-owned USA facilities without the use of artificial flavors, preservatives, or colors. Since each cup amounts to 429 calories, you want to make sure your pooch is getting enough physical activity to prevent unhealthy weight gain.
- Salmon is the #1 ingredient
- Salmon and salmon meal make up the protein content
- Barley, ground rice, and oatmeal provides fiber and complex carbs
- Sunflower oil and fish oil supplies high amounts of omega fatty acids
- Preserved naturally using animal fat and vitamin E
- Fortified with vitamins, minerals, and prebiotics
- 100% free of artificial ingredients
- Available in small breed and large breed formulas
- Not ideal for less active dogs due to its high-calorie content
- May not be suitable for dogs with grain intolerance
Purina PRO PLAN SAVOR Shredded Blend of Chicken & Rice for Adult Dogs
This savory recipe features chicken as its number one ingredient and main source of protein. Delicious and nutritious, it also supplies fat and other nutrients. The best part is that it comes with tender meaty bits that will tickle canine taste buds.
Your pooch will also receive a notable amount of dietary fiber since it contains rice flour, which is a gluten-free carbohydrate source. If that wasn’t enough, Purina added whole grain wheat as the third ingredient. Whole grain provides protein, fiber, manganese, niacin, and B vitamins, among others.
Moreover, Purina also added fish meal (ground and dried fish), soybean meal (ground and dried soybeans), beef tallow, and poultry by-product meals to raise the protein content and flavor profile further. Although the said ingredients are lower-quality compared to lean meat, it still provides important nutrients.
Purina has likewise assured its consumers that they follow safety and hygienic measures in terms of production. Additionally, this kibble has no artificial preservatives or dyes.
- Chicken is the #1 ingredient
- Comes with small chicken bits for added protein and flavor
- Rice flour and whole grain wheat provides complex carbohydrates and dietary fiber
- Preserved naturally using animal fat and vitamin E
- Fortified with vitamins, minerals, and prebiotics
- 100% free of artificial ingredients
- Available in puppy, small breed, large breed, and senior formulas
- May not be suitable for dogs with wheat, beef, or soy intolerance
- Contains undisclosed ingredients (poultry by-product meal and fish meal)
Purina ONE SMARTBLEND Chicken & Rice Recipe for Adult Dogs
The Purina ONE SMARTBLEND Chicken & Rice Recipe is more economical compared to the PRO PLAN varieties reviewed earlier. As could be expected, it contains less-than-stellar ingredients to compensate for its cheaper price tag.
On the bright side, it features paw-smacking chicken as its number one ingredient and main source of protein. Impressively, chicken by-product meal comes fifth in its list of ingredients. Know that rendered chicken offers three to four times the amount of protein compared to raw meat.
Rice is likewise added in the recipe to provide complex carbohydrates and dietary fiber. Dried carrots and peas are also added in the mix. While rice flour is considered a quality dog food ingredient, corn gluten meal and whole grain corn aren’t so much. Some dogs may develop allergic reactions to corn, but it isn’t actually as bad as others painted it to be.
Whole grain corn provides energy, fiber, and other nutrients. However, including corn among the top five ingredients isn’t ideal since they consist about 80% of the food’s weight.
- Chicken is the #1 ingredient
- Comes with protein-rich, tender meaty morsels
- Rice flour and whole grain corn provides complex carbohydrates and dietary fiber
- Preserved naturally using beef fat and vitamin E
- Fortified with vitamins and minerals
- Available in small breed and large breed formulas
- Contains the controversial ingredients “caramel color” and “liver flavor”
- May trigger allergic reactions in sensitive dogs due to corn and corn gluten meal
Purina ONE SMARTBLEND True Instinct for Adult Dogs
Finicky eaters would love to try the newly improved Purina ONE SMARTBLEND True Instinct due to its novel meats. Purina considers this formula as one of their premium offerings.
This particular recipe features turkey as its number one ingredient and main source of protein. Just like chicken, it is a healthy dog food ingredient, and it likewise provides glucosamine to support cartilage health and minimize inflammation.
To bump up the protein content, Purina added chicken meal as its second ingredient, which is more protein-concentrated than its raw form. Chicken meal used to rank fifth in the ingredients list in the original formula.
Additionally, there are meaty bits of turkey, chicken, and venison to give the food tantalizing taste and aroma. Overall, each serving delivers 30% protein to support lean muscles and a strong heart.
While I appreciate Purina for using “hypoallergenic” proteins, this recipe contains corn gluten meal and soy flour as the third and fourth ingredients, respectively. Corn gluten and soy flour provide proteins, but the bioavailability of amino acids is much lower than that of meats.
- Turkey is the #1 ingredient
- Delivers 30% protein sourced from turkey, chicken meal, and venison
- Comes with chicken, turkey, and venison meat morsels
- Preserved naturally using beef fat and vitamin E
- Fortified with vitamins and minerals
- Offers moderate calories per serving
- Available in small breed and large breed formulas
- Contains the controversial ingredient “caramel color”
- This could have been a hypoallergenic dog food without the soy and corn
Royal Canin German Shepherd Adult Dog Food
The ever-popular German Shepherd is best known for its courage, intelligence, and loyalty. The only weakness of this awesome breed is its sensitive digestive system. And if you give this smart canine something he doesn’t like, he will eat just enough not to starve. Thus, you will end up with a skinny, unhealthy pooch.
Therefore, Royal Canin formulated a specific diet that will not only fulfill the needs of the German Shepherd, but will also satisfy his palate. This formula contains digestible LIP proteins in the form of chicken by-product meal and pork meal.
Royal Canin also added Brewer’s rice, brown rice, and oat groats to provide your canine dynamo the energy he needs. These ingredients are likewise rich in fiber to promote proper digestion, speed up elimination, and stool consistency. Additionally, Royal Canin fortified this dog food with an array of vitamins and minerals.
For the price, quality, and customer feedback, I believe this is one of the best dog food you can give to your German Shepherd. However, Royal Canin is not without flaws.
- Features highly digestible proteins
- Contains carefully selected grains and fibers that promote digestion and bowel movement
- Enriched with EPA and DHA for brain, skin, heart, and cartilage health
- The kibble size, shape, and texture are suitable for the long and strong muzzle of the GSD
- Supplies 321 calories per cup
- Ideal for GSDs that are 15 months old or older
- A pricier option
- Contains corn and gluten meal
Royal Canin Labrador Retriever Adult Dog Food
A Lab’s love for food is as abysmal as his love for its guardian or fur-parents. I have yet to see a breed that can outmatch the appetite of a Lab! Since Labrador Retrievers are prone to obesity, it is best to feed these food-motivated canines a diet that is tailored to their lifestyle and personality. Your best option would be the Royal Canin Labrador Retriever formula.
As with most Royal Canin formulas, this kibble uses chicken by-product meal as its number one ingredient and main source of protein. A small portion of pork meal is also added in the mix to amplify its protein content. Overall, each cup of this dog food supplies 28% protein.
Since the playful Labrador is heavy and big-boned, he needs glucosamine to promote cartilage health, and this formula provides just that.
This food is likewise fortified with EPA and DHA to help prevent the early onset of arthritis and other joint-related problems. These fatty acids also nourish the skin and condition the coat.
At 275 calories, your playful pooch can easily maintain a healthy weight with this food.
- High in protein but moderate in calories
- Enriched with EPA and DHA to help support healthy joints and strong bones
- Donut-shaped kibble helps encourage Labs to chew their food, not swallow
- Helps maintain an ideal weight
- A more expensive option
- Contains corn and gluten meal
Purina ONE vs. Purina PRO PLAN Vs. Royal Canin: Face to Face Comparison
Nutritional Value
Let us kick things off by comparing Purina ONE vs. Purina PRO PLAN vs. Royal Canin in terms of the nutritional value of their best-selling products.
Model | Protein | Fat | Fiber | Calories per Cup | Nutrients | Key Benefits | Price |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
26% | 16% | 4% | 429 | B vitamins, vitamin A, vitamin E, vitamin C, vitamin K, glucosamine, omega-3, omega-6, zinc, iron, manganese, copper, calcium, choline | Sensitive Digestion Skin Allergies Weight Control High-Protein | Check Price | |
26% | 16% | 3% | 382 | B vitamins, vitamin A, vitamin E, vitamin C, vitamin K, glucosamine, zinc, manganese, iron, copper, calcium, biotin, choline, lysine, prebiotics | High-Protein | Check Price | |
26% | 16% | 3% | 383 | B vitamins, vitamin A, vitamin E, vitamin C, glucosamine, omega-6, niacin, folic acid, biotin, choline, calcium, zinc, selenium | High-Protein | Check Price | |
30% | 17% | 3% | 341 | B vitamins, vitamin A, vitamin E, vitamin C, glucosamine, omega-6, niacin, folic acid, biotin, choline, calcium, zinc, selenium | High-Protein | Check Price | |
22% | 17% | 5.5% | 321 | EPA, DHA, B vitamins, vitamin A, vitamin E, vitamin C, glucosamine, niacin, folic acid, biotin, choline, calcium, zinc, selenium | Breed Specific Sensitive Digestion Skin Allergies | Check Price | |
28% | 11% | 5.4% | 275 | EPA, DHA, B vitamins, vitamin A, vitamin E, vitamin C, glucosamine, niacin, folic acid, biotin, choline, calcium, zinc, selenium | Breed Specific Weight Maintenanc" | Check Price |
Ingredients
The Purina PRO PLAN range has the longest list of controversial ingredients. Even the pet food giant, Royal Canin, has a handful of ingredients that stir controversy. Although these ingredients don’t necessarily mean they are harmful, they have come under fire by consumers for various reasons.
Purina ONE | Purina PRO PLAN | Royal Canin |
---|---|---|
Animal digest | Animal digest | Brewer’s rice |
Animal fat | Animal fat | Caramel color |
Brewer’s rice | Brewer’s rice | Corn gluten meal |
Canola meal | Canola meal | Corn flour |
Caramel color | Canola oil | Dried tomato pomace |
Chicken by-product meal | Caramel color | Pea protein |
Corn germ meal | Chicken by-product meal | Pork by-products |
Corn gluten meal | Corn germ meal | Pork plasma |
Ground yellow corn | Corn grits | Powdered cellulose |
Liver | Corn gluten meal | Soybean protein isolate |
Meat by-product | Dried corn syrup | Tomato pomace |
Pea protein | Garlic powder | Wheat gluten |
Poultry by-product meal | Ground yellow corn | |
Powdered cellulose | Liver | |
Soybean hulls | Meat by-product | |
Soybean flour | Pea protein | |
Soybean protein concentrate | Poultry | |
Soybean protein isolate | Poultry by-product meal | |
Turkey by-product meal | Poultry giblets | |
Powdered cellulose | ||
Soybean hulls | ||
Soybean flour | ||
Soybean protein concentrate | ||
Soybean protein isolate |
Purina and Royal Canin have always strived to produce products for the best interest of our pets. Veterinarians and experts alike have spoken favorably of these brands. Personally, I am giving these companies the benefit of the doubt!
Royal Canin, in particular, is not ashamed of using meat meals and by-products. Although these ingredients sound unappetizing, the company insists that these ingredients are properly processed in their facilities, and they are even safe enough for human consumption.
Flavors
You can lead Doggo to his food, but you can’t make him eat – unless, of course, you make his mouth water.
There is no point in buying Doggo the most nutritious food you can afford if he refuses to eat it in the first place. Fortunately, Purina ONE and Purina PRO PLAN offer a variety of flavors that cater to dogs of all life stages, as well as those that have specific nutritional requirements.
Purina PRO PLAN, in particular, has made some upgrades in their formulas. The newly improved Purina Pro offered an array of new flavors without corn, soy, wheat, or poultry by-products. Among these exciting flavors include chicken and egg, beef and peas, beef and salmon, shredded turkey and chicken, turkey and barley, turkey and sweet potatoes, among many others.
On the other hand, Royal Canin remains an avid fan of chicken meat meals, by-products, and oils. Although this company has made countless formulas over the years, they seem to favor chicken flavor.
Variants
Variety is the spice of life, and if you have a picky eater, you know this adage is true!
Purina PRO PLAN offers five nutritional platforms:
- SAVOR: delivers a vivid flavor profile using all-natural ingredients
- BRIGHT MIND: specially formulated to improve cognitive health
- NATURAL: no corn, wheat, or soy
- FOCUS: focuses on unique nutritional requirements
- SPORT: provides athletic canines with strength and endurance
- SMARTBLEND: uses real meat as #1 ingredient, plus meaty morsels
- TAILORED: specialized diets to meet unique requirements based on age and size
- TRUE INSTINCT: nutrient-dense formulas with a multitude of flavors and grain-free options to choose from
Product Safety and Recalls
A product recall is a double-edged sword. While it has the potential to hurt a company’s reputation, it is also an opportunity for the company to demonstrate its commitment to customer safety. Providing prompt action also enhances customer loyalty.
- Purina PRO PLAN was recalled once on March 9, 2016, due to incorrect vitamins and minerals.
- Purina ONE was recalled once on August 30, 2013, due to Salmonella.
- Royal Canin was recalled thrice in May 2007 for melamine contamination, but these products do not include breed-specific diets.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Purina PRO PLAN contain grain?
Does Purina PRO PLAN contain taurine?
Is Purina ONE a high-quality dog food?
Who makes Royal Canin?
Why do veterinarians recommend Royal Canin?
Conclusion
Purina and Royal Canin both have a long history and hands-on experience in the pet food industry. Royal Canin is widely known and esteemed for their breed-specific and prescription diets. On the other hand, Purina is notable for their delicious recipes that provide excellent nutritional value at a more pocket-friendly price.
In the end, it is difficult to crown a winner when comparing Purina One vs. Purina Pro vs. Royal Canin because there are many factors to consider when buying pet food. Some pets need a diet high in carbs, while others don’t to shed off pounds; some pets need a diet heavy in protein, while others don’t to unburden the kidneys; and so forth.
A wise thing to do is to know the nutritional needs of your dog. Talk with your vet and trust SCIENCE, not trends. Veterinarians are great at assisting with this since they have to euthanize poor pets whose owners pay too much attention to trends and disregard science and solid evidence.
If I had to pick a favorite among the bunch, I would choose the Purina PRO PLAN FOCUS Sensitive Skin and Stomach Formula as my dog’s daily staple food. Although Purina ONE and PRO PLAN feature quality ingredients, I found the PRO PLAN range more superior.